Evaluating All-in-One Printers for Home Office Needs

Strategic Insights -

As home offices become increasingly common, the demand for multi-function machines that meet the needs of both Mac and PC users grows. Victoria Walker embarked on a search for a PC and Mac-compatible jet printer with a high-resolution scanner and fax capabilities that wouldn't overwhelm her workspace. After testing four all-in-one printers, she found that none perfectly met her requirements but identified the best options for different categories.

Key Takeaways:

  • The Hewlett Packard Laserjet 5140 stood out for its space-saving design, easy installation, and excellent print quality, despite lacking a flatbed scanner.
  • The Gestetner 4210 offered top-notch quality service, sharp laser printing, and accurate scanning, but its large "footprint" and sophisticated software made it less user-friendly.
  • The Epson Stylus 2500 worked as a standalone scanner and printer, with excellent printing clarity and quality, although it required computer operation for faxing and had no internal modem.
  • The Xerox WorkCentre XK35c was a compact, multifunction machine with a clear control panel, though it required careful setup and fine-tuning for optimal performance.
  • All tested machines were compatible with Apple Macintosh as well as PCs except for the Hewlett Packard Laserjet 5140.
  • The Epson Stylus 2500 and Xerox WorkCentre XK35c both provided colour icons showing ink levels, which was a helpful feature for office users.
  • The Xerox WorkCentre XK35c's fax option required scanning, saving, and sending to the computer's desktop fax program, which was found to be complicated.

Statistics:

  • The Hewlett Packard Laserjet 5140 measured 272mm x 390mm x 384mm, while the Gestetner 4210 measured 251mm x 439mm x 505mm, making Hewlett Packard the more space-efficient option.
  • The print resolution laser for the Gestetner 4210 was 600dpi, matching that of the Hewlett Packard Laserjet 5140.
  • The print speed for the Gestetner 4210 was 10ppm, outpacing the other machines, including the Hewlett Packard Laserjet 5140 at 6ppm.
  • The Epson Stylus 2500 was priced at Pounds 349, while the Gestetner 4210 was more expensive at Pounds 2113, but provided top-notch quality and service.

Sources:

  • The Times, "The Quest for the Perfect All-in-One Printer"
  • The following machines were tested:

+ Hewlett Packard Laserjet 5140

+ Gestetner 4210

+ Epson Stylus 2500

+ Xerox WorkCentre XK35c

  • Copyright (C) The Times, 2000