Penn State's Knee-Jerk Firing of James Franklin Undermines the Program's Progress

Strategic Insights -

Penn State football had a remarkable turnaround in the years following the Jerry Sandusky scandal, with coach James Franklin leading the team to three consecutive seasons with 10 or more wins. However, in a surprising move, Penn State's administration fired Franklin after a single losing season, citing his inability to beat top-ranked teams. The decision is seen as a reflection of the fast-food culture of accountability and the pressure to deliver immediate results.

Key Takeaways:

  • Franklin had five seasons (out of 12) with 11 victories or better, making him one of the most successful coaches in Penn State history.
  • His biggest weakness was his inability to beat top 10 teams, with a record of 4-21 against such opponents.
  • The decision to fire Franklin was reportedly influenced by adidas and NIL (Name, Image, and Likeness) sources, indicating the influence of external pressures on the program.
  • The firing of Franklin undermines the progress the program made under his leadership, including his ability to lead the team out of the aftermath of the Jerry Sandusky scandal.
  • Franklin's mistake this season might have been his failure to consider alternative quarterback options when Drew Allar faltered.
  • Penn State is likely to face a difficult time finding a replacement coach who can match Franklin's recruiting prowess.

Statistics:

  • 13-3: Penn State's record last season under Franklin, including a semifinal appearance in the College Football Playoff.
  • 3-3: Penn State's current record after losing three consecutive games to underdog teams.
  • 20 points or more: The margin of victory for Penn State's last two losses, to UCLA and Northwestern, a first in NCAA football history.
  • $49 million: The amount Penn State will pay Franklin to not coach.
  • 1-13: Franklin's record against rival Michigan and Ohio State when those teams were ranked in the top 10.

Sources:

  • The Tribune-Review (Greensburg, Pa.)
  • TribLIVE (www.triblive.com)
  • Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC