The Dark Side of Hockey Culture: Unpacking the Role of Pornography in Sexual Assault Cases

Strategic Insights -

The case of a young woman, referred to as E.M., who allegedly suffered group sexual assault at the hands of Canadian junior hockey players has brought the issue of pornography's influence on our culture back into the spotlight. During her trial, E.M. was accused of adopting a "porn-star persona," which led to discussions about the impact of pornography on young people. However, a closer look at the research suggests that blaming porn for alleged sexual assaults is misguided and may even be used to obfuscate the truth.

Key Takeaways:

  • The case of E.M. and the alleged group sexual assault by Canadian junior hockey players highlights the need for a broader discussion about the root causes of abuse in sports organizations.
  • Research suggests that there is no clear correlation between exposure to violent or aggressive pornography and an increased likelihood of engaging in violent or aggressive behavior.
  • Blaming pornography for alleged sexual assaults is a misguided attempt to shift the focus away from the responsibility of individuals and organizations to prevent and address abuse.
  • The hockey culture, including the use of power and control, is a significant contributing factor to the alleged sexual assaults in Canadian junior hockey.
  • The use of consent and communication is necessary in healthy relationships, including those in the sports world.
  • Research suggests that there is a significant disconnect between the portrayal of sex in pornography and real-life relationships.
  • The sex industry is a necessary part of societal conversation, especially when discussing consent and relationships.
  • There is a need for education and awareness about the differences between fantasy and reality, especially among young people.
  • The hockey culture and sports organizations must take responsibility for creating a safe and respectful environment for all players.
  • Addressing the root causes of abuse in sports organizations requires a comprehensive approach, including education, prevention, and support for survivors.

Statistics:

  • Between 1989 and 2005, Hockey Canada was aware of 21 sexual assault cases involving male players, but they were settled quietly without court hearings. (Source: The Globe and Mail)
  • Since 1989, Hockey Canada has paid $8.9 million to settle 21 cases of sexual assault. (Source: The Globe and Mail)
  • Between 2002 and 2005, Canadian junior hockey players were subjected to group sexual assaults, including physical and sexual abuse. (Source: Ontario Superior Court Justice Paul Perell's ruling)
  • In 2018, more than 30% of Canadian boys experienced bullying in sports, and 44% of coaches reported witnessing bullying. (Source: CBC News)
  • The majority of players, staff, and coaches in the Canadian Hockey League (CHL) experience hazing, including physical and sexual abuse. (Source: Ontario Superior Court Justice Paul Perell's ruling)

Sources:

  • The Globe and Mail, "Hockey Canada paid $8.9 million to settle 21 sexual assault cases, documents show"
  • CBC News, "Hockey Canada faces allegations of systemic abuse"
  • Ontario Superior Court Justice Paul Perell's ruling, "Carroll v. Canadian Hockey League"
  • The Hockey News, "Hockey Canada's Handling of Abuse Allegations Sparks Outrage"
  • Anti-Pornography Advocate, Andrea Werhun