Sign in Subscribe
International trade

Trump's Tariff Power Struggle: A Blow to Presidential Authority

Strategic Insights

— 1 min read

The US Court of International Trade has dealt a significant blow to President Donald Trump's authority to impose tariffs, ruling that most of the tariffs imposed by Trump were unlawful. Three judges of the USCIT struck down the tariffs, citing the American Constitution's principle that taxation, including tariffs, is the exclusive domain of the legislature, Congress. This ruling is a direct challenge to Trump's assertion that he has the power to impose any tariff he wants on any country, at any time, and for any reason.

Key Takeaways:

  • The US Court of International Trade ruled that most of the tariffs imposed by President Trump were unlawful, citing the American Constitution's principle that taxation, including tariffs, is the exclusive domain of the legislature.
  • The court held that the International Emergency Economic Powers Act 1977 (IEEPA) did not authorize the president to impose unlimited tariff authority, as that would be unconstitutional.
  • The court found that Trump's Worldwide Retaliatory Tariffs were unauthorized because they exceeded the authority granted to the president and improperly used the IEEPA.
  • The Trafficking Tariffs were also found to be unlawful because they did not deal with the threats identified in the orders imposing tariffs, specifically drug smuggling.
  • The court set the parameters between Congress and the executive, holding that the president cannot directly or completely take over powers that belong to Congress, as stated in the American Constitution's checks and balances.
  • This ruling is a significant blow to Trump's assertion that he has the power to impose any tariff he wants on any country, at any time, and for any reason.

Statistics:

  • The US Court of International Trade ruled on the tariffs imposed by President Trump.
  • The tariffs in question were the Worldwide Retaliatory Tariffs and the Trafficking Tariffs.
  • The court struck down most of the tariffs imposed by Trump.
  • The IEEPA 1977 did not authorize the president to impose unlimited tariff authority.
  • The Trade Act 1974 is the proper statute to deal with trade imbalances.
  • The tariffs did not deal with the threats identified in the orders imposing tariffs.

Sources:

  • US Court of International Trade (USCIT) judgement
  • International Emergency Economic Powers Act 1977 (IEEPA)
  • Trade Act 1974
  • American Constitution
  • Alper Ali Riza's article on the topic, attributed to the original text.

Read more