Sign in Subscribe
Theft

The Revolutionary Right: How MAGA Embraces Leftist Ideas to Destroy the Left

Strategic Insights

— 2 min read

A peculiar alignment has occurred in American politics, where right-wing groups, particularly MAGA, have begun to incorporate leftist ideas into their arsenal to dismantle the left. This phenomenon has been fueled by the cold war between the revolutionary right and the progressive left, with the latter having let its movement be captured by a failed revolutionary left-wing ideology. As a result, the right has effectively co-opted leftist ideas, stripping them of their original intent to build a more just society and using them instead to tear down the existing power structures.

Key Takeaways:

  • MAGA has adopted postmodernist ideas, which suggest that truth is relative and constructed narratives are used to impose power. This has been exemplified in Trump's statements, where truth is whatever he says it is.
  • The movement has also exploited anti-globalization sentiments, using the idea of a shadowy elite controlling America's politics to fuel its narrative of a "deep state" conspiracy.
  • MAGA has drawn inspiration from Marxist-Leninist ideology, specifically the concept of a vanguard leading a revolution to destroy the existing power structures.
  • Critical Theory, a post-Marxist intellectual movement, has also been co-opted by MAGA. Trump has taken the idea of supposedly neutral institutions being sham masks of elite power and flipped it on its head, portraying cultural studies professors as the oppressors and evangelical Christians as the oppressed.
  • The concept of identity politics has been turned on its head, with MAGA using it to justify its policies as identity politics for white people.
  • Transgressivism, a left-wing cultural phenomenon that aims to shock the bourgeois, has also been adopted by MAGA. Examples include the use of deliberately offensive language and the embracing of conspiracy theories.
  • The right has also taken up cancel culture, but with a twist. While the left uses it to ostracize those who offend, MAGA uses it to offend and destroy careers with words that were previously considered safe.
  • The left, particularly the Democratic Party, has struggled to find a more moderate intellectual tradition to replace its failed radical ideologies.

Statistics:

  • Since the 1999 WTO protests, anti-globalization sentiments have been exploited by MAGA to fuel its narrative of a "deep state" conspiracy.
  • Between 2013 and 2017, Steve Bannon made several statements praising Lenin's tactics, including saying he wanted to "bring everything crashing down and destroy all of today's establishment."
  • A 2020 Politico report documented a Republican group text chat that shared deliberately transgressive and performatively right-wing statements.
  • Last year, a writer named James Lindsay submitted a right-wing reworked version of the Communist Manifesto to a conservative publication, which was later revealed to be a hoax.

Sources:

  • Antonio Gramsci, "The Prison Notebooks" (original work, no date specified)
  • Jonathan Rauch, "The Case Against Postmodernism" (Persuasion, no date specified)
  • C. Wright Mills, "The Power Elite" (1956)
  • Peter Dale Scott, "The Road to 9/11" (2007)
  • Marcel Duchamp, "Fountain" (1917)
  • Andres Serrano, "Piss Christ" (1987)
  • Sam Francis, "A Time for Rethinking" (no date specified)
  • Christopher Rufo, various writings and interviews (no specific sources cited)

Read more