Sign in Subscribe
Executive power

Supreme Court to Hear Case on Trump's Authority to Impose Tariffs

Strategic Insights

— 2 min read

The Supreme Court will hear arguments this week on President Donald Trump's authority to impose sweeping tariffs on imported goods, a decision that typically falls under Congressional authority. The case, filed by educational toy manufacturer Learning Resources Inc., argues that Trump misused the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) to impose tariffs on nearly all imported goods from nearly all countries. The lawsuit claims that the tariffs have caused significant losses for the company, forcing it to lay off employees and increase prices.

Key Takeaways:

  • The Supreme Court will hear arguments on President Trump's authority to impose tariffs, a decision typically made by Congress.
  • Learning Resources Inc. sued Trump in April, accusing him of misusing the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) to impose tariffs.
  • The lawsuit claims that the tariffs have caused significant losses for the company, forcing it to lay off employees and increase prices.
  • The IEEPA allows the president to use executive authority to implement sanctions on foreign terrorists and hostile nations representing a threat to the United States.
  • The statute does not mention tariffs or duties, and no president has invoked IEEPA to impose a tariff or duty until Trump.
  • The Supreme Court may struggle to decide whether trade deficits constitute an emergency under the IEEPA.
  • Large corporations have stayed out of the legal fight, with experts suggesting they are worried about retribution from the president.
  • Experts say that the federal government has immense leverage and power that can upend a business with a tweet or a tax investigation.

Statistics:

  • 10% tariffs were imposed on nearly all imported goods from nearly all countries (Source: [1])
  • The tariffs were imposed by Trump in April (Source: [1])
  • Learning Resources Inc. had to lay off employees and increase prices due to the tariffs (Source: [1])
  • The Supreme Court expects to hear arguments on Wednesday (Source: [1])
  • The Illinois-based company has accused Trump of misusing the IEEPA (Source: [1])

Sources:

  • [1] Nov. 3 (UPI) -- "Supreme Court set to hear Trump tariff case"
  • [2] September (Source: [1]) -- The Supreme Court granted an expedited review of the case.
  • [3] April (Source: [1]) -- Learning Resources Inc. filed the lawsuit, and Trump imposed 10% tariffs.
  • [4] The New York Times, November 3 (Source: [5]) -- Tara Leigh Grove, a University of Texas at Austin professor of law, said that the IEEPA appears to give the president a lot of leeway in its use.
  • [5] CNN (Source: [6]) -- Gregory Shaffer, a professor at Georgetown University Law Center, said that some companies are trying to be more careful with this administration.
  • [6] Nov. 3 (UPI) -- A small, family-run wine company, VOS Selections, also sued Trump over his use of tariffs.

Read more