Sign in Subscribe
Airbus S.A.S.

Airbus's Subsidy Conundrum: Will the Era of Government Support End?

Strategic Insights

— 1 min read

The Paris Air Show saw the Airbus A380 make its debut, a massive aircraft with a price tag supported by a staggering €3 billion in government loans. The aviation industry is accustomed to government support, especially for military aircraft, but the EU-US treaty of 1992 has set off a dispute over subsidies. The European Commission, led by Neelie Kroes, Competition Commissioner, seeks to modify the rules on state aid, pushing for more support for smaller firms and innovation. This development raises questions about the future of Airbus, particularly with its CEO, Noel Forgeard, claiming the company can dispense with government aid for the A350 project.

Key Takeaways:

  • The European Commission aims to reassess the rules on state aid, prioritizing support for smaller, entrepreneurial firms and innovation.
  • Neelie Kroes wants to limit state aid for big companies, such as Airbus, and redirect it towards more innovative projects.
  • Airbus's CEO, Noel Forgeard, surprisingly stated that the company could manage without government launch aid for the A350, challenging the conventional wisdom on subsidies.
  • The controversy surrounding state aid is being evaluated by the World Trade Organisation, while the European Commission seeks reform.
  • Airbus and Boeing rely heavily on government support, with subsidies helping keep aircraft prices low.
  • Airlines like Emirates, Singapore Airlines, and Ryanair, which are cost-conscious and efficient, do not require heavy subsidies to remain competitive.
  • The shift in government support could lead to more expensive aircraft, impacting airlines with tighter budgets.

Statistics:

  • €3 billion: The amount of government loans supporting the Airbus A380 project.
  • 43: The number of A380s ordered by Emirates, which will use these aircraft to challenge European carriers.
  • 20%: The percentage of airlines that are financially challenged, primarily those receiving post-9/11 subsidies and nationalised EU carriers.
  • $9 billion: An estimated annual loss for the entire European airline industry due to subsidies.
  • €2 billion: The annual support provided by the European Union to Airbus through the EADS company.

Sources:

  • "Europe challenges Boeing's big Pentagon grants" by Lynn Davidson, The Times, 2005.
  • "Subsidy War: EU fires first shot in battle with US over Boeing" by Mark Courtenay, The Times, 2006.

Read more