Sign in Subscribe
County councils

Councillors Threaten Legal Action Against Council in Attempt to Have Mosque Lease Withdrawn

Strategic Insights

— 2 min read

Residents in Abergavenny have been left divided following the news that a group of councillors are planning to take legal action against the council in an attempt to have the lease for the former library building turned into a mosque withdrawn. Three Conservative councillors, along with a local resident, have formally notified Monmouthshire County Council that they will begin legal proceedings if the lease to the Monmouthshire Muslim Community Association is not withdrawn. The council had previously approved a £6,000 per year lease for the 120-year-old grade II-listed building, which is intended to be used as a community centre and mosque.

Key Takeaways:

  • Three Conservative councillors and a local resident are planning to take legal action against the council to have the lease for the former library building turned into a mosque withdrawn.
  • The councillors have raised concerns over religious impartiality, transparency, and the proper use of public assets.
  • The council had approved a £6,000 per year lease for the 120-year-old grade II-listed building, which is intended to be used as a community centre and mosque.
  • The council has been criticized for its decision-making process, with some councillors describing it as "hidden unaccountable secretive".
  • The Monmouthshire Muslim Community Association is currently without a dedicated place of worship, having to rent the Catholic church hall.
  • The council has until Friday, September 19 to respond to the letter before any formal legal proceedings begin.

Statistics:

  • £6,000: The annual rent paid by the Monmouthshire Muslim Community Association for the use of the former library building.
  • £4,000: The original cost of building the library in 1905.
  • 120 years: The age of the former library building, which is listed as a grade II building.
  • 4 weeks: The duration of the competitive tender process for the lease.
  • 2015: The year when the library service transferred to the town hall, leading to the closure of the library.
  • Friday, September 19: The deadline for the council to respond to the letter before any formal legal proceedings begin.

Sources:

  • Abergavenny Chronicle: "Councillors threaten legal action against council in attempt to have mosque lease withdrawn"
  • Christian Concern: "Council taxpayers need to know that the council is adhering to its values of openness, transparency and fairness in its use of limited council resources and not operating in a hidden unaccountable secretive way." (Cllr Brown)
  • Local Democracy Reporting Service: "Councillors were dissatisfied with how concerns were addressed during the call in, which included part of a meeting being held in confidential session." (Cllr Buckler)
  • Abergavenny Chronicle: "The bottom line is Abergavenny has got a rich history of non-conformism dating right back to the 17th century when Christians in Abergavenny fought peacefully for religious freedom." (Rev Gareth Wilde)
  • Christian Concern: "This case raises serious questions about transparency, fairness, and the proper use of public assets. The people of Abergavenny deserve to be heard, and their concerns must not be brushed aside." (Andrea Williams, chief executive of the Christian Legal Centre)

Read more