Sign in Subscribe
Legislators

Florida Lawmakers Sue Governor DeSantis Over Denied Access to Immigration Detention Center

Strategic Insights

— 2 min read

Florida lawmakers Shevin Jones, Carlos Guillermo Smith, Michele Rayner, Anna Eskamani, and Angie Nixon filed a lawsuit in the Florida Supreme Court against Governor Ron DeSantis and Florida Department of Emergency Management Executive Director Kevin Guthrie, alleging that their exclusion from the Alligator Alcatraz immigration detention center violated state law and the Florida Constitution. The lawmakers claim that their exclusion from the facility, which was open to the media and other state Republicans, undermined the separation of powers and improperly restricted their authority as co-equal branch of government. The detention center, which has a capacity for 3,000 people, has been plagued by reports of poor conditions, including inadequate sanitation and extreme temperatures.

Key Takeaways:

  • The lawsuit, filed on behalf of state Sens. Shevin Jones and Carlos Guillermo Smith and state Reps. Michele Rayner, Anna Eskamani, and Angie Nixon, alleges that Governor DeSantis and FDEM Director Kevin Guthrie denied them access to the Alligator Alcatraz immigration detention center on July 3, citing "safety concerns."
  • The lawmakers claim that this denial violates state law and the Florida Constitution, as they are entitled to conduct unannounced visits to any state or local detention facility at their "pleasure" under Florida Statutes 944.23 and 951.225.
  • The detention center, which opened on July 1, has been the subject of controversy, with reports of poor conditions, including inadequate sanitation and extreme temperatures.
  • The governor's office responded to the lawsuit, calling it "frivolous" and stating that the state is looking forward to "quickly dispensing with this dumb lawsuit."
  • The lawsuit was filed by attorneys Ashley Gantt and LaVon Bracy Davis, both Democratic members of the Florida House.
  • Two environmental groups, the Friends of the Everglades and the Center for Biological Diversity, have already sued the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), FDEM, and Miami-Dade County over the construction of the detention center, alleging violations of a federal law requiring environmental analysis and public comment.
  • The governor's office has announced that the detention center will be open for tours by all state lawmakers and members of Congress this Saturday for a 90-minute visit.

Statistics:

  • 5,000: The estimated number of immigrant detainees expected to be housed at the 3,000 person-capacity tent and trailer detention center.
  • 3: The number of days that some detainees have reportedly gone without showering.
  • 1: The number of tour groups given access to the facility on July 1, which included President Donald Trump, Governor DeSantis, and several other state Republicans.
  • 90: The length of time allotted for tours of the facility this Saturday.

Sources:

  • "Five Democratic lawmakers sue DeSantis over denied access to immigration detention center." Florida Phoenix, 2025-07-11.
  • "State offers tour of immigrant detention center for state lawmakers, U.S. reps." Florida Phoenix, 2025-07-09.
  • "Report of poor conditions at Alligator Alcatraz detention center." Miami Herald, 2025-07-07.
  • "CBS News: Alligator Alcatraz detainees allege inhumane conditions at immigration detention center." CBS News, 2025-07-07.

Read more