Sign in Subscribe
Prime ministers

France's Twin Crises: Fiscal and Political Woes Engulf Macron's Government

Strategic Insights

— 1 min read

France faces a grim situation with its twin crises - fiscal and political troubles - feeding into each other, eroding the country's standing in the EU and threatening President Emmanuel Macron's legacy. French Prime Minister Francois Bayrou's confidence vote is widely seen as a sign of political suicide, given the gulf with opposition parties. Despite his efforts to prioritize the problem, Bayrou's minority government faces insurmountable challenges in addressing the fiscal crisis, with its public debt standing at 114% of GDP.

Key Takeaways:

  • France's public debt is at 114% of GDP, the highest in the Eurozone.
  • Bayrou's government has proposed €44bn in spending cuts and tax rises for next year as part of a four-year plan to pare back the budget deficit to 3% of GDP.
  • The country needs to run a long-term primary surplus, before interest payments, of 1% of GDP to stabilise its debt level.
  • France has only managed a primary surplus once in the past 30 years, whereas Italy has done so roughly 25 times during the same period.
  • Italy was once seen as a byword for instability and profligacy, highlighting the striking role reversal with France.
  • Macron's options are limited, with appointing a new premier unlikely to gain majority support for a budget.
  • The opposition parties' attachment to increasing spending and tax plans makes finding a deal with the Socialists difficult.
  • Rolling over the budget or passing a new one by decree could further complicate the situation.
  • Macron's decision to dissolve parliament again could risk shrinking the ranks of his centrist coalition and potentially hand power to the far right.

Statistics:

  • France's public debt stands at 114% of GDP.
  • The budget deficit is at 5.8% of GDP in 2024.
  • The Council of Economic Analysis has recommended a long-term primary surplus of 1% of GDP to stabilise the debt level.
  • France has only achieved a primary surplus once in the past 30 years.
  • Italy has managed a primary surplus roughly 25 times in the past 30 years.

Sources:

  • "France's twin crises: fiscal and political woes engulf Macron's government", Financial Times, [no date provided]
  • Council of Economic Analysis, "Economic Analysis of France"

Read more