Sign in Subscribe
Tariffs

Global Economic Instability: A Shift in Consensus Narrative

Strategic Insights

— 2 min read

The high confidence in American economic exceptionalism, which peaked at the January World Economic Forum at Davos, gave way to deep pessimism about a recession and global order fragmentation. The market has reflected these swings, with the S&P index experiencing a 20% drop followed by a 14% rebound. The Vix, or "fear index," has been on a wild rollercoaster ride, and the yield on the 10-year US government bond has fluctuated within a 0.80 percentage point range since February.

Key Takeaways:

  • The consensus economic narrative has shifted from high confidence in American economic exceptionalism to deep pessimism about a recession and global order fragmentation.
  • The S&P index has experienced unusual market volatility, falling 20% and then rebounding 14% in just three months.
  • The Vix, or "fear index," has been highly volatile, reflecting traders' anxiety about market uncertainty.
  • The yield on the 10-year US government bond has fluctuated within a 0.80 percentage point range since February, a rare occurrence.
  • The usual correlation between a stronger dollar and lower US Treasury yields has been reversed in times of turmoil.
  • The US trade tariff policy has been a major contributor to the volatility in the consensus economic narrative.
  • The tariffs are seen as an accelerant of structural shifts in the global economy, including the failure of individual countries to grow strongly, inclusively, and sustainably.
  • The global economy is at risk of venturing into unknown and uncomfortable territory due to the persistence of structural forces.
  • Governments, companies, households, and investors should treat this moment as one needing corrective actions at home and better co-ordinated international approaches to common problems.

Statistics:

  • S&P index fell 20% from its peak in February (Source: [N/A])
  • S&P index rebounded 14% in the past four weeks (Source: [N/A])
  • Vix, or "fear index," has been on a wild rollercoaster ride (Source: [N/A])
  • Yield on the 10-year US government bond fluctuated within a 0.80 percentage point range since February (Source: [N/A])
  • The dollar's usual correlation with lower US Treasury yields has been reversed in times of turmoil (Source: [N/A])
  • US trade tariff policy has been a major contributor to the volatility in the consensus economic narrative (Source: [N/A])

Sources:

  • Mohamed El-Erian, president of Queens' College, Cambridge, and an adviser to Allianz and Gramercy
  • World Economic Forum, January 2023 meeting at Davos
  • US financial markets data, February 2023 to present
  • Economic research and analysis by Mohamed El-Erian

Read more