Sign in Subscribe
Prime ministers

Imran Khan's Misquote: A Critical Review of His Use of the Responsibility to Protect Principle

Strategic Insights

— 2 min read

The international community has been left concerned after Prime Minister Imran Khan used the United Nations' Responsibility to Protect (R2P) principle in a tweet, claiming it necessitates humanitarian assistance to Afghanistan. However, foreign policy experts and former diplomats have criticized this statement, arguing that R2P is a principle related to preventing genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing, and crimes against humanity, and not humanitarian assistance. The misuse of this principle raises questions about the Prime Minister's understanding of foreign policy and the role of the Foreign Ministry in drafting and vetting official statements.

Key Takeaways:

  • Prime Minister Imran Khan mistakenly used the Responsibility to Protect (R2P) principle to appeal for humanitarian assistance to Afghanistan, sparking criticism from foreign policy experts and former diplomats.
  • The R2P principle is a UN principle adopted in 2005 by the UN General Assembly resolution, which relates to preventing genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing, and crimes against humanity, not humanitarian assistance.
  • Since August 15, 2021, Afghanistan has been facing an acute shortage of food, and liquidity issues in banks have exacerbated the crisis.
  • Reema Omer, an adviser for International Commission for Jurists, stated that R2P has no relevance to the humanitarian crisis in Afghanistan, and the Prime Minister should not have mentioned it.
  • Najmus Saqib, a former special secretary at the Foreign Office, termed the Prime Minister's statement as the "biggest blunder" and emphasized the need for the Foreign Ministry to vet official statements.
  • Shamshad Ahmed, Pakistan's former Ambassador to the UN, defended the Prime Minister's statement, arguing that his sincerity should be recognized, and the technical explanation of R2P's applicability should be ignored.
  • Former Foreign Secretary Inamul Haq emphasized that R2P should not be used to make humanitarian appeals and suggested that the UN should instead call an international donor conference to address the crisis in Afghanistan.

Statistics:

  • Since August 15, 2021, Afghanistan has faced an acute shortage of food, and liquidity issues in banks have exacerbated the crisis.
  • The UN General Assembly adopted the R2P principle in 2005.
  • The R2P principle was initially invoked in the context of the Rwandan genocide by UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan.

Sources:

  • The Nation (Pakistan newspaper, date not specified)
  • Reema Omer, adviser for International Commission for Jurists, tweet (date not specified)
  • Najmus Saqib, former special secretary at the Foreign Office, interview with The Nation (date not specified)
  • Shamshad Ahmed, Pakistan's former Ambassador to the UN, interview with The Nation (date not specified)
  • Inamul Haq, former Foreign Secretary, interview with The Nation (date not specified)

Read more