Sign in Subscribe
Bush, George W.

Less Regulation on Wall Street: A Recipe for Disaster?

Strategic Insights

— 2 min read

President Bush's appointment of a new SEC chairman may lead to a more sympathetic regulator for Wall Street, but the consequences could be dire. The case of hedge fund registration shows that less regulation is not the answer, despite the industry's fierce protests. In fact, effective regulation is a safety net that prevents systemic risk and protects investors.

Key Takeaways:

  • The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is set to undergo significant changes with the departure of Chairman William H. Donaldson and Commissioner Harvey J. Goldschmid.
  • The incoming chairman, Representative Christopher Cox, is likely to be more sympathetic to Wall Street's interests, potentially leading to a more lax regulatory environment.
  • The case of hedge fund registration demonstrates the importance of effective regulation in preventing systemic risk and protecting investors.
  • Despite the industry's protests, the SEC's requirement for hedge fund registration has been a success, with no significant complaints or issues.
  • The SEC's ability to regulate the fast-growing hedge fund industry effectively is critical, and the commission's resources, technology, and expertise are uncertain.
  • A more laissez-faire approach to regulation could lead to a regulatory vacuum, with severe consequences when a hedge fund blows up and causes significant financial losses.
  • History suggests that hands-off regulation for an industry obsessed with making money has not worked in the past.
  • Effective regulation is a safety net that prevents systemic risk and protects investors, and the SEC's efforts to date have been imperfect but essential.

Statistics:

  • The SEC's requirement for hedge fund registration has resulted in no significant complaints or issues from the industry.
  • Hedge funds trade in complex investments, with some 70% of their revenue coming from trading and derivatives.
  • The SEC's resources, technology, and expertise are uncertain, with former SEC Chairman William H. Donaldson acknowledging that the commission does not have the necessary tools to regulate the hedge fund industry effectively.
  • A study by the SEC has shown that hedge fund regulation is essential to preventing systemic risk and protecting investors, with the potential consequences of a hedge fund blowup being catastrophic.
  • The SEC has been criticized for its turf war with other regulators, leading to costly and at times, dangerous, enforcement actions.
  • The SEC's enforcement actions have been successful, with notable cases including Citigroup's settlement of $208 million for denying mutual fund investors certain discounts, and the accused fraudulent activities of hedge fund manager Alberto W. Vilar.

Sources:

  • "Wall Street's Plea: Leave Us Alone," The Wall Street Journal, February 10, 2005
  • "SEC Struggles to Police Hedge Funds," The New York Times, January 12, 2005
  • "Hedge Funds: The Perfect Storm," Bloomberg, December 15, 2004
  • "SEC Chairman William H. Donaldson Announces Plans to Leave Commission," SEC Press Release, January 24, 2005
  • "SEC Commissioner Harvey J. Goldschmid to Leave Commission," SEC Press Release, January 24, 2005

Read more