Long-term Field Experiments Reveal Key to Sustainable Agriculture Practices

Researchers from the Walloon Agricultural Research Center in Gembloux, Belgium, have conducted a 65-year study to evaluate the long-term effects of agricultural practices on soil organic carbon (SOC) storage. The study, funded by the Walloon Region within the INDIGGES project, reveals that long-term field experiments (LTEs) are crucial for understanding the impact of organic matter management practices on SOC storage. The researchers analyzed a time series of topsoil SOC content from 1959 to 2021 and found that cattle manure application led to the most significant SOC storage, increasing topsoil SOC stock and content by approximately 20% over the long term.

Key Takeaways:

  • The study emphasizes the importance of long-term field experiments (LTEs) in evaluating the long-term effect of agricultural practices on soil organic carbon (SOC) storage.
  • Cattle manure application led to a 20% increase in topsoil SOC stock and content over the long term, making it the most significant SOC storage method among the studied organic matter management practices.
  • Pig slurry application, cereal straw incorporation, and cover crops cultivation resulted in smaller, non-significant SOC increases of about 5%, but the combined effects of these practices were cumulative, leading to significant SOC accruals.
  • The subsoil SOC stock was unaffected by the organic matter management practices.
  • Annual humified C inputs, calculated from livestock manures and crop residues, correlated strongly with SOC content in the topsoil (r = 0.8), indicating that the quantity and quality of C inputs are key drivers of SOC storage.
  • The study highlights the complexity of interpreting time series of data from LTEs, where the evolution of management practices over time may act as confounding factors.

Statistics:

  • A 20% increase in topsoil SOC stock and content for cattle manure application over the long term.
  • A 5% increase in topsoil SOC stock and content for pig slurry application, cereal straw incorporation, and cover crops cultivation.
  • A cumulative 15% increase in topsoil SOC stock and content for the combined effects of these practices.
  • A r = 0.8 correlation between annual humified C inputs and SOC content in the topsoil.
  • A 65-year duration of the long-term field experiment.
  • A time series analysis from 1959 to 2021 for topsoil SOC content.

Sources:

  • European Journal of Agronomy, 2025;170.
  • Soil Organic Carbon Stocks and Dynamics Under Contrasting Organic Matter Management Practices - Results From a 65-year-old Experiment In Belgium.
  • Walloon Agricultural Research Center, Dept Sustainabil Syst & Prospectives, Unit Soil Water & Integrated Crop Prod, Rue Du Bordia 4, B-5030 Gembloux, Belgium.
  • NewsRx, Researchers from Walloon Agricultural Research Center Detail New Studies and Findings in the Area of Agriculture (Soil Organic Carbon Stocks and Dynamics Under Contrasting Organic Matter Management Practices - Results From a 65-year-old ...). Agriculture Week. September 4, 2025; p 377.