Soccer players

Manchester United's Big Mistake: Former Coach Claims Selling McTominay Was a Critical Error

Strategic Insights

Jul 1, 2025 — 1 min read

Benni McCarthy, a former Manchester United coach, has spoken out about the club's decision to sell midfielder Scott McTominay to Napoli last summer. According to McCarthy, United's decision to let McTominay go was one of the biggest mistakes in football history. McTominay was an instant hit at Napoli, leading the team to the Serie A title in his debut season and being voted Serie A Player of the Season. United sold McTominay to help comply with profit and sustainability regulations, but McCarthy believes the move was a major error.

Key Takeaways:

Manchester United's decision to sell Scott McTominay to Napoli was one of the biggest mistakes in football history, according to former coach Benni McCarthy.
McTominay was a crucial part of Napoli's Serie A title-winning campaign, being voted Serie A Player of the Season.
United sold McTominay to help comply with profit and sustainability regulations, with his £25.7 million fee counting as pure profit on the balance sheet.
Former coach Benni McCarthy pushed for United to sign Liverpool forward Cody Gakpo, but the club's scouting department vetoed the move.
McCarthy believes Gakpo would have been an ideal signing for United, providing an additional attacking option alongside Marcus Rashford.
The scouting department's decision to veto Gakpo's transfer was based on statistical analysis, but McCarthy argues that this approach overlooks the importance of instinct and player evaluation.

Statistics:

Scott McTominay's transfer fee to Napoli was £25.7 million.
McTominay was voted Serie A Player of the Season after helping Napoli win the title.
Napoli won the Serie A title in their first season with McTominay, who played a crucial role in their campaign.
Cody Gakpo signed with Liverpool for an unknown fee.
McDonald, Benni (2024, February 22). "Manchester United’s big mistake: Why Benni McCarthy thinks Scott McTominay's sale was a huge error." betonlinepromocodes.com.
Sky Sports (2024, March 1). "Manchester United's major mistake: Benni McCarthy claims selling Scott McTominay was a huge error."

The End of American Hypergrowth

For two centuries, the US economy grew by adding workers. That's over.

Healthcare's $5.3 Trillion Drag

How Medical Spending Became America's Biggest Productivity Tax

Breakthrough in Nanotechnology: Electromagnetic Shock Treatment Shows Promise

Researchers at the Wuhan University of Technology in China have made significant progress in the field of nanotechnology, specifically in the area of nanoindentation. A novel electromagnetic shock treatment (EST) method has been developed to enhance the microscale mechanical properties of a titanium alloy, with promising results obtained through array-based

Gut Microbiota Plays Crucial Role in Immunotherapy Success for Colon Cancer Patients

Research investigators at the Zhengzhou Central Hospital Affiliated to Zhengzhou University have made groundbreaking discoveries on the role of gut microbiota in determining the efficacy of immunotherapy for colon cancer patients. The study, which was recently published in Biochimica et Biophysica Acta, reveals that specific bacterial species and microbial metabolites

Read more

The End of American Hypergrowth

Healthcare's $5.3 Trillion Drag

Breakthrough in Nanotechnology: Electromagnetic Shock Treatment Shows Promise

Gut Microbiota Plays Crucial Role in Immunotherapy Success for Colon Cancer Patients