Soccer players

Manchester United's Decision to Let Scott McTominay Leave Deemed "One of the Biggest Mistakes in Football"

Strategic Insights

Jul 6, 2025 — 1 min read

Manchester United's decision to let Scotland international Scott McTominay join Napoli last summer has been described as "one of the biggest mistakes in football" by one of his former Old Trafford coaches. The 28-year-old Scottish superstar ended his 22-year association with the Red Devils on deadline day last summer, joining the Italian giants in a deal worth around £27.5million alongside fellow Scotland international Billy Gilmour. McTominay's departure has been met with regret from the club and its former coaches, who believe the decision to let him leave was a significant mistake.

Key Takeaways:

Former Manchester United first team coach Benni McCarthy believes the club made a significant mistake by letting Scott McTominay leave.
McCarthy, who worked with McTominay during the 2022/23 and 2023/24 seasons, thinks the decision should have never been allowed to happen.
Scott McTominay was a key player for Manchester United, with former coach McCarthy describing him as a player who "had fight" and was "born to play for United."
McCarthy believes the club should have retained McTominay due to his importance to the team, and that the decision to let him go was a significant error.
McTominay's departure was part of a larger transfer deal that saw him and Billy Gilmour join Napoli in a deal worth around £27.5million.
Napoli's signing of Scott McTominay was seen as a significant coup, with the midfielder helping the club win the Serie A title in his debut season.
McTominay's success at Napoli has been described as a "shock" by some in the football world, given his departure from Manchester United.

Statistics:

Scott McTominay achieved 12 league goals in his debut season at Napoli.
McTominay broke Denis Law's 63-year record for the most goals scored by a Scotsman in a single Serie A season.
Manchester United sold Scott McTominay to Napoli for around £27.5million.
Napoli won the Serie A title in McTominay's debut season.

Sources:

betonlinepromocodes.com
The Scotsman
sports website (not explicitly stated, but mentioned as Fabrizio Romano)

The End of American Hypergrowth

For two centuries, the US economy grew by adding workers. That's over.

Healthcare's $5.3 Trillion Drag

How Medical Spending Became America's Biggest Productivity Tax

Breakthrough in Nanotechnology: Electromagnetic Shock Treatment Shows Promise

Researchers at the Wuhan University of Technology in China have made significant progress in the field of nanotechnology, specifically in the area of nanoindentation. A novel electromagnetic shock treatment (EST) method has been developed to enhance the microscale mechanical properties of a titanium alloy, with promising results obtained through array-based

Gut Microbiota Plays Crucial Role in Immunotherapy Success for Colon Cancer Patients

Research investigators at the Zhengzhou Central Hospital Affiliated to Zhengzhou University have made groundbreaking discoveries on the role of gut microbiota in determining the efficacy of immunotherapy for colon cancer patients. The study, which was recently published in Biochimica et Biophysica Acta, reveals that specific bacterial species and microbial metabolites

Read more

The End of American Hypergrowth

Healthcare's $5.3 Trillion Drag

Breakthrough in Nanotechnology: Electromagnetic Shock Treatment Shows Promise

Gut Microbiota Plays Crucial Role in Immunotherapy Success for Colon Cancer Patients