Sign in Subscribe
Murder

Missouri Inmate's Bid to Reopen Case Over Unconstitional Sentencing Denied

Strategic Insights

— 2 min read

Deandra Buchanan, a Missouri inmate serving a life sentence for a 2000 murder conviction, has lost his bid to reopen his case after a lower court ruled that the Missouri Supreme Court's reduction of his death sentence to life without parole was constitutional. Buchanan argued that he was unconstitutionally denied an in-person resentencing hearing, citing federal court precedent and state law that requires defendants to be present when their sentence is pronounced. However, Boone County Circuit Judge Jeff Harris disagreed, stating that the Supreme Court's action did not require further action from the trial court.

Key Takeaways:

  • Deandra Buchanan, a Missouri inmate, lost his bid to reopen his case over unconstitutional sentencing after a lower court ruled against him.
  • Buchanan was originally sentenced to death for a 2000 murder conviction but had his sentence reduced to life without parole by the Missouri Supreme Court in 2003.
  • Buchanan argued that he was unconstitutionally denied an in-person resentencing hearing, citing federal court precedent and state law.
  • Judge Jeff Harris disagreed, stating that the Supreme Court's action did not require further action from the trial court.
  • Buchanan has claimed that he has no memory of the crime and believes his sentencing is unconstitutional due to a lack of finality.
  • The case raises questions about the rights of defendants to be present during critical stages of their sentencing process.

Statistics:

  • Buchanan has been serving a life sentence for over 20 years.
  • The Missouri Supreme Court reduced Buchanan's sentence from death to life without parole in 2003.
  • Buchanan's case has been ongoing for over two decades, with the latest ruling coming in 2025.
  • Buchanan has spoken publicly about his case in an episode of the Netflix series "I am a Killer."

Sources:

  • [Missouri Independent, April 11, 2025, Bolton, Lindsay. "A Missouri inmate had his death sentence reversed, but it left him stuck in legal limbo."](https://missouriindependent.com/2025/04/11/a-missouri-inmate-had-his-death-sentence-reversed-but-it-left-him-stuck-in-legal-limbo/)
  • [Missouri Supreme Court, 2003, Case No. SC92423. Buchanan v. State.](https://revisor.mo.gov/main/OneSection.aspx?section=565.035&bid=29277)
  • [FindLaw, Supreme Court of the United States, 2022. No. 21-976. Daniels v. Georgia.](https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/us-supreme-court/375/162.html)
  • [Missouri Independent, April 11, 2025, Bolton, Lindsay. "A Missouri inmate had his death sentence reversed, but it left him stuck in legal limbo."](https://missouriindependent.com/2025/04/11/a-missouri-inmate-had-his-death-sentence-reversed-but-it-left-him-stuck-in-legal-limbo/)

Read more