Sign in Subscribe
Attorneys general

New York Appeals Court Throws Out $500 Million Judgment Against Donald Trump

Strategic Insights

— 2 min read

A New York appeals court has dismissed the approximately $500 million judgment against President Donald Trump in the civil fraud case brought by the state's attorney general. The decision, announced on Thursday, leaves Trump liable for fraud but jettisons the penalty. Trump still faces other legal challenges, including his 2024 conviction in the New York hush money case and a federal case related to the mishandling of classified documents.

The appeals court's ruling is the latest example of a court reducing or dismissing legal action taken against Trump. Trump was indicted four times in 2023 and has faced numerous other lawsuits and investigations. Despite the decision, New York Attorney General Letitia James plans to appeal the ruling to the state's highest court.

The appeals court's decision was not unanimous, with four judges agreeing that Trump and his company were liable for fraud and three judges dissenting. The majority opinion stated that while the injunctive relief ordered by the lower court was well-crafted to curb defendants' business practices, the disgorgement order of nearly half a billion dollars was an excessive fine that violated the Eighth Amendment of the United States Constitution.

CNN senior legal analyst Elie Honig described the ruling as "monumental" and a "huge win" for Trump. Trump himself hailed the decision as a "total victory" and a "stinging rebuke" to James.

Key Takeaways:

  • The New York appeals court threw out the approximately $500 million judgment against President Donald Trump in the civil fraud case brought by the state's attorney general.
  • The decision leaves Trump liable for fraud but eliminates the penalty.
  • The ruling is the latest example of a court reducing or dismissing legal action taken against Trump, who was indicted four times in 2023 and faces numerous other lawsuits and investigations.
  • New York Attorney General Letitia James plans to appeal the ruling to the state's highest court.
  • The appeals court's decision was not unanimous, with four judges agreeing that Trump and his company were liable for fraud and three judges dissenting.
  • The majority opinion stated that while the injunctive relief ordered by the lower court was well-crafted, the disgorgement order was an excessive fine that violated the Eighth Amendment.
  • Trump still faces other legal challenges, including his 2024 conviction in the New York hush money case and a federal case related to the mishandling of classified documents.
  • The court split decision was outlined in 322 pages.

Statistics:

  • The dismissed judgment was worth approximately $500 million.
  • The court's disgorgement order was worth $354 million initially, with interest, totaling roughly $500 million.
  • The lower state court correctly found Trump and his company liable for fraud.
  • The appeals court agreed to lower the bond Trump was required to post to $175 million.
  • Trump still faces numerous other lawsuits and investigations.

Sources:

  • CNN: "New York appeals court throws out $500 million judgment against Donald Trump"
  • CNN: "Letitia James plans to appeal ruling that tossed $500 million judgment against Trump"
  • CNN: "Trump's lawyers hail 'total victory' as court tosses $500 million judgment against him"

Read more