Sign in Subscribe
City councils

Newcastle's Parks Charity Wound Up Amid Financial Vulnerability Concerns

Strategic Insights

— 1 min read

Newcastle's opposition councillors have blasted the creation of a charity to manage the city's parks, calling it a "woefully lacking" decision that put the green spaces at risk. The Urban Green Newcastle charity was established in 2019 to oversee 33 parks and over 60 allotments, with the aim of saving the city over £110 million over a 125-year lease. However, the charity is being wound up after the council pulled support, citing financial vulnerabilities and concerns over the trust's finances.

Key Takeaways:

  • An independent review found that the charity was left "financially vulnerable" due to factors such as the impact of Covid-19, lack of cash reserves, and absence of contingency arrangements.
  • The review highlighted "overly optimistic" assumptions made by the council when considering the charity model and a lack of independent oversight or challenge.
  • The opposition Liberal Democrats had criticized the charity from the start, warning of financial planning issues and a lack of robust performance indicators.
  • The charity's costs ran £2.7 million higher than expected between 2019 and 2024.
  • The review stated that the city's parks were "in a state of disrepair" in 2019, but a comprehensive survey had not been conducted to assess the scale of the challenge.
  • Labour's Alex Hay defended the decision to transfer management of the parks to the charity, citing the independent evaluation's recognition of the council's vision and the impact of unforeseen factors.

Statistics:

  • The charity's costs ran £2.7 million higher than expected between 2019 and 2024.
  • Over 33 parks and more than 60 allotments were transferred to the charity in 2019.
  • The charity was established with the aim of saving the city over £110 million over a 125-year lease.
  • The council's understanding of the scale of the challenge faced by the parks was not assessed via a comprehensive survey in 2019.

Sources:

  • "Newcastle's parks trust set up with 'woefully lacking' due diligence, report finds" by The Local Democracy Reporting Service, last week
  • "Fuel Research's report for UGN and the National Trust"
  • "Labour defends decision to wind up parks trust after independent review" by The Local Democracy Reporting Service, earlier this year
  • "Newcastle City Council"
  • "Fuel Research"

Read more