Sign in Subscribe
Teachers

Oskaloosa High School Art Teacher Sues District over Termination

Strategic Insights

— 1 min read

Matthew Kargol, a 12-year veteran art teacher at Oskaloosa High School, has filed a lawsuit against the school district after being fired over a social media post he made following the Charlie Kirk shooting. The post, which the district claims disrupted the learning environment, was characterized by Kargol's lawyers as "rhetorical hyperbole" and not related to his employment. The lawsuit disputes the district's claim of disruption and alleges that Kargol was terminated due to his expressed viewpoint, which the district publicly condemned. Kargol's lawyers argue that he was silenced and punished for exercising his constitutional right to free speech.

Key Takeaways:

  • The Oskaloosa School Board voted to terminate Matthew Kargol's contract after a closed session meeting on Wednesday, September 17.
  • Kargol's lawsuit claims that his social media post was "rhetorical hyperbole" and not related to his employment with Oskaloosa Schools.
  • The lawsuit disputes the district's claim that the post disrupted the learning environment, citing the absence of any evidence of disruption in the classroom.
  • Kargol's profile did not identify him as a school district employee, and his post was not made in the classroom, during working hours, or using school resources.
  • The lawsuit alleges that the district's actions were motivated by public disapproval of Kargol's speech, rather than a genuine concern for the learning environment.
  • Kargol has been a teacher at Oskaloosa High School since 2012 and was also a coach for wrestling and track and field.
  • The lawsuit cites the district's receipt of over 1,200 phone calls from community members upset about the post as evidence of a "politically motivated pressure campaign".
  • Kargol's lawyers argue that he was silenced and punished for exercising his constitutional right to free speech.

Statistics:

  • Oskaloosa School Board voted to terminate Matthew Kargol's contract on Wednesday, September 17.
  • Kargol has been a teacher at Oskaloosa High School for 12 years (2012-present).
  • The district received over 1,200 phone calls from community members upset about the post.

Sources:

  • Kelby Wingert (KCCI) - "Oskaloosa teacher sues district after being fired over social media post" (KCCI)

Read more