Sign in Subscribe
Emigration and immigration

Reality Show Proposal for Immigrants Competing for US Citizenship Spreads Amid Controversy

Strategic Insights

— 2 min read

As the United States weighs the merits of allowing a reality show where immigrants compete against one another for US citizenship, officials in Washington have been presented with proposals for the show drawn up by Rob Worsoff, the creator of the hit reality series Duck Dynasty. The concept, detailed in a 35-page pitch for "The American," would follow pre-vetted contestants arriving at Ellis Island, competing in various challenges across the country, and ultimately earning citizenship for the winner. Critics have expressed concerns that the show could be seen as sensationalizing the immigration process and unfairly penalizing those who do not succeed.

Key Takeaways:

  • The Department of Homeland Security is considering proposals for a reality show where immigrants compete against one another for US citizenship, drawn up by Rob Worsoff, the creator of Duck Dynasty.
  • The show, titled "The American," would start with pre-vetted contestants arriving at Ellis Island, competing in challenges across the country, and ultimately earning citizenship for the winner.
  • The competition format has sparked controversy, with critics arguing it could be seen as a "hunger game" for immigrants and unfairly penalize those who do not succeed.
  • Worsoff, 49, insists the show is not about deporting losers, but rather a celebration of the immigration process and a national conversation about what it means to be American.
  • The show has been pitched during the Obama and Trump administrations, with the current administration showing interest in the proposal.
  • The Department of Homeland Security has confirmed the proposals are "under consideration," but have not been seen by Secretary Kristi Noem.
  • Immigrants in the US already participate in the Green Card Lottery, with up to 55,000 participants each year.

Statistics:

  • 35-page pitch for "The American" reality show was drawn up by Rob Worsoff in consideration for the Department of Homeland Security.
  • Over 55,000 US immigrants participate in the Green Card Lottery each year, known officially as the Diversity Immigrant Visa.
  • The Green Card Lottery was introduced in 1990 under the Immigration Act, with bipartisan support.
  • Secretary Kristi Noem has posed in front of caged prisoners in El Salvador's notorious mega-prison Cecot, sparking controversy regarding her stance on immigration.

Sources:

  • "U.S. considering reality show where immigrants compete against one another for citizenship" by Dailymail.com
  • "DHS responds to criticism of 'ICE Barbie' Kristi Noem's El Salvador visit, says Trump admin 'appreciates' public criticism of administration on immigration" by Federal News Network
  • "US Senators Want Reform of Diversity Visa Program" by Senator Elizabeth Warren's official website

Read more