Sign in Subscribe
United States

Social Security's Financial Future Hinges on Immigration, Report Warns

Strategic Insights

— 2 min read

As Congressional leaders prepare for a public relations battle over Social Security's future, a new report highlights the critical role immigration will play in determining the program's financial health. The study, authored by Stuart Anderson, finds that rising or falling immigration rates could have significant effects on the system's deficit. The report's findings come as lawmakers head home for town hall meetings, where they will face questions from constituents about Social Security and the proposed private investment accounts.

Key Takeaways:

  • The Social Security system's financial shortfall in the decades ahead will depend on immigration rates, with a 10% reduction in the deficit possible if legal immigration rises by one-third over the next 75 years.
  • If the number of immigrants falls by one-third, the retirement system's shortfall will worsen by 10%.
  • Immigrants typically contribute taxes to the system for decades before claiming benefits, strengthening the system's financing.
  • The report was written by Stuart Anderson, a senior official at the Immigration and Naturalization Service and executive director of the National Foundation for American Policy.
  • The study found that new workers entering the country would contribute $611 billion in Social Security taxes over the next 75 years, in 2005 dollars.
  • President Bush's proposed guest worker program could strengthen the Social Security system by allowing illegal immigrants to pay Social Security taxes.
  • The Democratic leadership has opposed President Bush's plan to permit workers to divert part of their Social Security taxes into private investment accounts.

Statistics:

  • 10% reduction in the Social Security deficit possible if legal immigration rises by one-third over the next 75 years.
  • 10% worsening of the retirement system's shortfall if the number of immigrants falls by one-third.
  • $611 billion in Social Security taxes contributed by new workers entering the country over the next 75 years, in 2005 dollars.
  • 600,000 new legal immigrants and 300,000 new illegal immigrants enter the country each year.
  • 611 billion in Social Security taxes contributed by new workers entering the country over the next 75 years, in 2005 dollars.

Sources:

  • Anderson, S. (author). (n.d.). The Impact of Immigration on Social Security. National Foundation for American Policy.
  • Merage Foundation for the American Dream. (n.d.). The Merage Foundation for the American Dream. Retrieved from [www.meragefoundation.org](http://www.meragefoundation.org)
  • The New York Times. (n.d.). Senators Get Ready for a War Over Social Security's Future. Retrieved from [www.nytimes.com](http://www.nytimes.com)
  • Associated Press. (n.d.). CAPTION(S): Photos: Senator Harry Reid leads Democratic attacks over Social Security. (Photo by Evan Yucci/Associated Press); Senator Rick Santorum is a big supporter of the president's plan. (Photo by Charles Dharapak/Associated Press)

Read more