Sign in Subscribe
Prime ministers

Starmer Announces Publication of Evidence in China Spying Case Amid Accusations of Cover-up

Strategic Insights

— 1 min read

Following the controversial collapse of the case against two individuals accused of passing sensitive intelligence to the Chinese Communist Party, Sir Keir Starmer has announced that he will publish the witness statement given by Matthew Collins, the deputy national security adviser, about the case. This move comes after accusations of a cover-up by the Government and demands for transparency from Sir Keir's critics. The row revolves around what evidence the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) had requested from the Government and why it was not provided.

Key Takeaways:

  • The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) had requested evidence from the Government that China was a "threat" to national security, which ministers claimed was impossible to provide.
  • The CPS dropped charges against Christopher Cash and Christopher Berry, who were accused of passing sensitive intelligence to the Chinese Communist Party.
  • Sir Keir Starmer's office knew that the case was on the brink of collapse "a couple of days" before the CPS told the court, but the Prime Minister claims he did not intervene.
  • The witness statements given by Matthew Collins will be published, but it remains unclear what specific evidence would have cleared the legal bar for the prosecution to succeed.
  • Sir Keir told MPs that Mr. Collins had written his witness statements without any interference from ministers or politically appointed special advisers.
  • The Government has denied any interference in the case, but critics argue that ministers were aware of the potential diplomatic backlash from China.
  • The Chinese government has made repeated requests to the UK to approve its new "super embassy" in east London, but it is unclear if any Chinese government officials raised the Cash and Berry case with the UK.

Statistics:

  • The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) dropped charges against Christopher Cash and Christopher Berry.
  • Sir Keir's office was informed of the case's impending collapse three days before the CPS notified the court.
  • 2021: the year the Integrated Review was conducted, which bookended the period when the alleged spying took place.
  • 2023: the year the Integrated Review Refresh was conducted.

Sources:

  • BBC News (date unknown)
  • The Telegraph (date unknown)
  • PA Wire (date unknown)

Read more