Sign in Subscribe
Emigration and immigration

Trump Administration Wins Ruling on Data-Sharing Agreement with Immigration Authorities

Strategic Insights

— 1 min read

A federal judge has declined to block a disputed Trump administration initiative that shares taxpayer information with immigration authorities to identify and deport undocumented immigrants. District Judge Dabney Friedrich rejected arguments from immigrant-rights groups that claimed the data-sharing arrangement between the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) violated taxpayer confidentiality laws. The decision is a victory for President Donald Trump's immigration agenda. The Trump administration had argued that the cooperation between the IRS and ICE would help to protect Americans by removing potentially dangerous immigrants who entered the country illegally.

Key Takeaways:

  • The data-sharing deal allows the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to ask the IRS to confirm home addresses of suspected undocumented immigrants who are defying deportation orders.
  • The agreement was pushed through in early April over the objections of several top career IRS officials, who refused to sign it due to legal concerns.
  • The IRS can share data to aid criminal investigations, but the tax agency cannot share data solely to facilitate deportations, which are a civil matter.
  • Judge Friedrich concluded that the Trump administration crafted the data-sharing deal carefully enough to comply with the law, despite the immigrant groups' claims that it was a thinly veiled pretext to get around the law.
  • The judge also emphasized that the Memorandum only allows sharing information for criminal investigations and that DHS must comply strictly with the limited exception on which they relied.
  • The immigrant-rights groups that filed the case could appeal the ruling to the DC Circuit Court of Appeals.

Statistics:

  • None mentioned in the article.

Sources:

  • CNN, "Federal judge won't block Trump administration's data-sharing deal with immigration authorities" (no date)
  • CNN, "Trump administration's data-sharing deal with immigration authorities sparks controversy" (no date)
  • Alan Morrison, attorney for the immigrant-rights groups (statement quoted in the article)
  • Perlman, Jennifer (July 6, 2019), "Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross's NASA contract has expired, the agency announced in an email to employees last month."

Read more