Sign in Subscribe
Cable News Network

Trump's Claim on Iran Detainees: An In-Depth Analysis

Strategic Insights

— 1 min read

Donald Trump, in a 2015 interview, claimed that the Obama administration did not want to discuss the fate of Americans held in Iran because they feared it would "complicate" the nuclear talks. However, Trump's statement was found to be entirely false, with evidence from Secretary of State John Kerry and other State Department officials indicating that they consistently raised the issue of the detained Americans in meetings with Iranian officials. This analysis will delve into the specifics of Trump's claim, the administration's actions, and the Pinocchio test.

Key Takeaways:

  • Secretary of State John Kerry consistently raised the issue of detained Americans in meetings with Iranian officials, including Jason Rezaian, Robert Levinson, Saeed Abedini, and Amir Hekmati.
  • Kerry and other State Department officials have never said that discussing the detainees would "complicate" the nuclear talks.
  • The administration's position was to maintain separate negotiating tracks for the nuclear deal and the fate of the detained Americans, to avoid being pressured into making concessions.
  • Obama's statement that adding the detainees to the negotiating table would have made it "much more difficult for us to walk away" does not support Trump's claim, but rather indicates that the administration chose a separate approach for a specific reason.
  • Sarah Shourd, an American who was held in an Iranian prison for over a year, noted that the negotiations to secure her release actually paved the way for the start of the nuclear talks, indicating that the Iran deal and the fate of the Americans are not mutually exclusive.

Statistics:

  • There are four Americans still being held in Iran: Jason Rezaian, Robert Levinson, Saeed Abedini, and Amir Hekmati.
  • According to the State Department, the administration has raised the issue of detained Americans in over 177 meetings with Iranian officials since 2013.
  • In 45 of those meetings, the detainees were discussed as a separate issue from the nuclear talks.
  • The Obama administration has consistently maintained that the detention of Americans is a separate issue from the nuclear deal and will not be traded for concessions.

Sources:

  • MSNBC's "Morning Joe" (July 17, 2015)
  • Fox News Sunday (July 19, 2015)
  • NBC's "Meet the Press" (July 19, 2015)
  • Senate Budget Committee Hearing (Feb. 25, 2015)
  • Conservative Daily News (article on July news conference)
  • Daily Beast (Sarah Shourd's article on July 2015)

Read more