Sign in Subscribe
Legislative bills

Work Requirements for Medicaid and TANF: Weighing the Benefits and Burdens

Strategic Insights

— 2 min read

Republican lawmakers in the House of Representatives have passed a bill that includes massive tax and spending cuts, with a significant portion of the controversy centered around provisions aimed at reducing the cost of Medicaid. The popular healthcare program, which is funded jointly by the federal and state governments, covers around 78.5 million low-income and disabled individuals, representing more than 1 in 5 Americans. As part of this effort, the bill proposes that anyone enrolled in Medicaid who appears capable of working must satisfy work requirements or lose their coverage. However, the effectiveness of such mandates is a topic of ongoing debate, with evidence suggesting that they may do more harm than good.

Key Takeaways:

  • Work requirements for low-income programs like Medicaid and TANF have been a point of contention in the House bill, with proponents arguing they can help individuals become self-sufficient and opponents arguing they increase administrative burdens and may lead to people losing essential benefits.
  • The current policy debate centers around a provision that would require Medicaid enrollees to work or lose their coverage, echoing the approach taken in the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) program.
  • Research on TANF has indicated that while work requirements can lead to employment among some recipients, many others end up in deep poverty as they struggle to meet the requirements.
  • The administrative burden of complying with work requirements is particularly challenging for people with unpredictable work schedules, inconsistent access to child care, or caregiving responsibilities.
  • Caseloads for TANF have dropped in some states by more than 50% despite significant population growth, mainly due to recipients getting jobs that pay them too much to qualify.
  • The Congressional Budget Office attributes the increase in employment among less-educated single mothers in the 1990s to work requirements, although not all recipients who stopped receiving cash through TANF became employed.
  • The implementing of work requirements could have a significant impact on Medicaid, with more than a dozen states seeking to apply for waivers to introduce the policy.
  • The Arkansas experience, which saw 18,000 people lose their Medicaid coverage with no significant increase in employment, serves as an example of the potential pitfalls of work requirements.

Statistics:

  • Medicaid covers over 78.5 million low-income and disabled individuals, equivalent to more than 1 in 5 Americans (Source: Kaiser Family Foundation).
  • The Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) program has a federal funding cap of $16.5 billion, which has remained flat since 1996, resulting in inflation-adjusted funding half that of when the program was established (Source: Center on Budget and Policy Priorities).
  • The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) subjects able-bodied adults without dependents to work requirements, allowing them to receive benefits for only three months within a three-year period if they are not employed (Source: USDA).
  • More than a dozen states have applied for waivers to introduce work requirements for Medicaid, with Arkansas and Georgia being the most notable examples (Source: Kaiser Family Foundation).
  • The number of people getting cash assistance through TANF has decreased significantly since the program replaced Aid to Families with Dependent Children, with caseloads dropping in some states by over 50% despite population growth (Source: Urban Institute).
  • The Congressional Budget Office has linked the increase in employment among less-educated single mothers in the 1990s to work requirements in programs like TANF (Source: Congressional Budget Office).
  • The administrative burden of complying with work requirements can lead to paperwork difficulties and disparate treatment by caseworkers, which is often informed by stereotypes (Source: Russell Sage Foundation).

Sources:

  • Kaiser Family Foundation, "Medicaid Enrollment and Unwinding Tracker"
  • Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, "Chart Book: TANF at 20"
  • USDA, "Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP)"
  • Kaiser Family Foundation, "Section 1115 Waiver Tracker: Work Requirements"
  • Congressional Budget Office, "Estimated Budget Effects of the FY 1997 Budget Resolution"
  • Urban Institute, "How Has TANF Caseload Changed Over Time?"
  • Russell Sage Foundation, "Administrative Burden"

Read more